Disclaimer: this is not my original recipe. These Greek Yogurt Bagels were made from a recipe my mom and sister raved about from Mess for Less that I followed pretty much to the tee.
Greek Yogurt Bagel Ingredients
The recipe calls for four ingredients, and you likely have most or all of them home already, plus toppings.
- Flour
- Salt
- Baking Powder
- Greek Yogurt (I used Fage Total 0% since that is what Mess for Less used)
- Trader Joe’s Everything Bagel seasoning (but this larger version ships FREE from Walmart)
Making Greek Yogurt Bagels
Let’s get the dough on the road!
These measurements yield 4 bagels. Simply adjust up or down (jk no one makes less bagels) for more bagels.
1. Add 1 1/2 tsp of baking powder, 1/2 tsp of salt and 1 cup of flour together in a mixing bowl and mix together. This creates self-rising flour so your bagels are nice and fluffy.
2. Add in 1 cup of Greek Yogurt to the bowl with the newly mixed self-rising flour and mix it all together with a spoon or your hands (it was slightly easier with my hands, but be sure to flour your hands before diving in to avoid too much sticking).
3. The dough will be crumbly and a little resistant at first, but keep working with it. Once you feel it’s as stuck together as it will be, take out the lump of dough and place on a floured surface.
Pro Tip: for my baking newbies, a floured surface will help keep dough from sticking to literallyΒ everything. Same concept in the previous step with rubbing some flour on your hands before mixing/kneading. Note the cutting board in the picture below for a visual.
4. Break the dough into 4 equal parts and roll each into a solid ball.
Now is a good time to pre-heat the oven to 350 degrees.
5. Roll each ball out into a line, about 7 inches or longer, depending what you want your final bagel shape to look like, and mend the ends together to form a complete circle shape.
Seasoning and Baking Your Greek Yogurt Bagels
1. Once rolled into bagel form, I sprayed the top with cooking spray and added the Trader Joe’s Everything Bagel Seasoning. (Edit: we now use this Everything But the Bagel seasoning due to free shipping and larger quantity – we FLY through it!)
Tip: I added the seasoning to the bagel over a small bowl. I found the seasoning didn’t stick all that easily so I scooped up the excess and added back to the bagel. An alternative might be to lay out some seasoning on a sheet and press the bagel into it.
2. Bake at 350 degrees for 23 minutes. Remove, then set the oven to 450 degrees, then bake for another 2 minutes. This browns the outside nicely. I kept mine on the top rack for the last 2 minutes to brown the top but avoid burning the bottom.
3. I laid mine on a cooling rack to cool. You could also move to a plate or even pick the tinfoil up and place the whole setup on the counter. I just wouldn’t leave them on the baking tray if you’re afraid the bottom may keep browning.
Greek Yogurt Bagels Nutrition
Before toppings, your bagel comes out to about 145 calories each, which is just unheard of! If you add the TJ’s Everything Bagel seasoning, and I highly recommend you do, it’s still only 150 calories per bagel (it’s TOTALLY worth it the extra 5 calories #treatyoself).
Weight Watchers Freestyle Points
These guys as-is are only 3 points on the Weight Watchers Freestyle program, which my mom and sister are all about thanks to my upcoming wedding (sorry not sorry guys π ) and they were so thrilled to find something so delicious. Shout out again to Mess for Less on an amazing recipe that I plan to sub in for dough all over the place!
Other Bagel Topping Ideas
Some other ideas for toppings that I am already thinking about include jalapeΓ±os, cheese and maybe some fruit ones for Kevin. I’m also hard pressed to try and make a Tomazzo Bagel, a favorite of mine from Great American Bagel.
I literally could not believe what I was eating when I tried them for the first time. They taste just like store-bought bagels! If you give them a try let me know what you think, because I think I’ll be making them all. the. time.
Update: Second Greek Yogurt Bagel Attempt
I’d mentioned that the seasoning didn’t stick as great as I’d thought, so the second time I made them I put the seasoning in a small, flat dish and pressed the bagel into it.
See how much fuller the coverage is? First try versus second try pictured below. I believe this will help the seeds stay on better!
Have you made them yet? Let me know how it went in the comments. And be sure to sure any fun ingredients you added to yours!
